thanks for the replies!

I plan on feeding dry only - and if I have to give Toby about 3 oz a day, that would cost me $30/month. I can live with that. Its double what I'm paying now though - and I won't last as long as Hill's SD.

For Lily, I can only get kitten in 47 oz bags - that would cost me about $20. 1 bag would last me about 15 days. Thats another $40/month.

Total = $70/month for cat food. Is this a bit outrageous? Do you guys pay that much? Wow ... I don't know if I can spend that much =/ I really like the Wellness brand, but its just VERY expensive.